“Waste no more time arguing what a good man should be. Be one.”

Washington Says It’s Helping Small Businesses. I’m Not Buying It.

By Matthew Oliver, Owner of House of Oliver, Roseville, California

I’ve owned and operated House of Oliver in Roseville, California, for nearly 13 years. And if there’s one thing I’ve learned about running a small business, it’s this: when somebody tells you they’re going to save you money, you’d better read the fine print.

That’s especially true when the promise is coming out of Washington, D.C.

Right now, Congress is considering legislation known as the Durbin-Marshall credit card mandates, part of the Credit Card Competition Act. Supporters are pitching it as a way to lower credit card processing fees and help small businesses like mine.

Sounds great, right? After all, what business owner wouldn’t want to pay less in fees?

But here’s the problem. When you start looking beyond the sales pitch, you have to ask a pretty important question: Is this really about helping small businesses, or is it another Washington bait-and-switch that benefits the biggest corporations in America?

I know firsthand what it takes to keep a restaurant running. For almost 13 years, my wife and I have dealt with rising food costs, increasing labor expenses, insurance, utilities, regulations, and just about every other challenge you can imagine. We’ve made payroll, created jobs, supported our community, and taken the financial risks that come with owning a business.

Believe me, I don’t need anyone in Washington explaining to me that credit card processing fees are expensive. I see those fees every single month.

So when someone comes along promising to lower them, I’m listening.

But I’m also paying attention to what they’re not telling me.

The Durbin-Marshall proposal would require certain credit cards to operate on at least two payment networks, changing how transactions can be routed. Supporters argue that increased competition would reduce processing costs.

But there’s no guarantee those savings would actually make their way to small businesses like mine, much less to the customers walking through our doors.

Meanwhile, the potential consequences deserve a lot more attention than they’re getting.

Let’s start with security.

Every day, customers at House of Oliver hand us their credit cards and trust that their information will be protected. That’s not something I take lightly.

The payment networks we use today have invested heavily in fraud prevention and cybersecurity. Changing the system could introduce new risks, and I want to know who will be responsible when something goes wrong.

Because here’s the reality: when a customer has a bad experience at my restaurant, they’re not going to call their congressman. They’re going to call me.

Then there are credit card rewards.

I know some politicians and lobbyists like to dismiss rewards points and cash back as little perks that don’t really matter. But to ordinary families and small business owners, those benefits can make a real difference.

Like many business owners, I use credit cards to purchase supplies and manage expenses. The rewards we earn help offset some of the costs of doing business.

And our customers use those same benefits to stretch their household budgets.

When groceries, gas, insurance, and just about everything else cost more than they did a few years ago, why would we want to put those benefits at risk?

Research from the University of Miami has estimated that small businesses could lose more than $1 billion in credit card rewards under this proposal, while the nation’s five largest retailers could collectively save more than $1 billion.

Think about that for a minute.

We’re being told this legislation is supposed to help small businesses compete, yet some of the biggest potential winners could be the largest retailers in America.

That’s not exactly my definition of leveling the playing field.

This past September, I had the opportunity to travel to Washington, D.C., with the Small Business Alliance and meet with members of California’s congressional delegation.

I didn’t go as a lobbyist or a policy expert. I went as someone who actually owns a business, employs people, pays the bills, and understands what happens when government policies sound good on paper but create problems in the real world.

And that’s a perspective Washington needs to hear more often.

Small business owners aren’t asking for special treatment. We’re asking for a fair opportunity to compete, reasonable regulations, and the freedom to make decisions that are best for our businesses and our customers.

If Congress genuinely wants to help small businesses, I’m all for it. Let’s talk about reducing unnecessary regulations, lowering the cost of doing business, and creating an environment where entrepreneurs can succeed.

But don’t tell us a bill is designed to help Main Street if the biggest benefits could end up going to Wall Street and America’s largest retailers.

After nearly 13 years in business, I’ve learned to recognize when a deal sounds a little too good to be true.

And from where I’m standing, the Durbin-Marshall credit card mandates deserve a lot more scrutiny and a lot less salesmanship.

Congress should stand with the small businesses and families it represents and reject this proposal.

Because helping small businesses shouldn’t just be a talking point. It should actually help small businesses.

Picture of Matthew Oliver

Matthew Oliver

House of Oliver
Address: 3992 Douglas Blvd., Ste. 140, Roseville, Ca, 95661
HouseofOliver.com
Facebook

Tags

Share this post:

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit, sed do eiusmod tempor incididunt ut labore et dolore